All Things Bookish | How I rate books

In this post I’ll explain how I rate books. I feel like a lot of people think a 3-star rating is bad, but to me it’s not bad at all. Luckily, I don’t read a lot of books that were really awful, so I don’t use 1 and 2-star ratings a lot. But I do use 3-star ratings quite often, since I read a lot of books that are good but not mind-blowing. You will be able to find this post under the tab ‘about’ as well.


I give 1-star and 2-star ratings to books I didn’t enjoy.

★ | 1 star – garbage

I did not like this book at all. Reading this book was a waste of time. I probably finished it because it’s a review copy and I have to review it. If I didn’t have to review this book I wouldn’t have finished it.

★★ | 2 stars – meh

This book isn’t good. It had some interesting elements that I liked but overall I didn’t enjoy it as much as I thought I would.

From here on – a 3-star rating – I would consider a book good.

★★★ | 3 stars – good

A good book I enjoyed reading. There are some things the author needs to work on, but overall I liked this book. Depending on what I didn’t like, I would or would not recommend the book

★★★★ | 4 stars – great

Really loved this book. It was great read and I would read it again. I’ll recommend this book.

★★★★★ | 5 stars – amazing

Amazing. Chef’s kiss. This book had an impact on me and I urge you to read it. This book was such an easy read that really got to me. I loved everything about it and can’t stop thinking about it.


Sometimes I do feel like a whole number does not concur with my feelings on the book. For example, I often feel like a 3-star rating is too low but a 4-star rating too high. I will give the books 3,5 stars because it’s just a bit better than a 3-star book.

2 thoughts on “All Things Bookish | How I rate books

  1. Ashmita | thefictionaljournal's avatar

    That’s a really interesting and fun way to rate books! 🙂….and you literally said garbage😂🤣

    1. heavenlybookish's avatar

      😂😂😂 yes I literally couldn’t think of any other word

Leave a Reply

Discover more from heavenlybookish

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close